|
|
|
http://www.neurotransmitter.net/adhdscales.html is a link for free rating scales. Connor's Abbreviated Rating Scale is shown below, a total of more than 15 is suggestive of ADD/ADHD:
SNAP Checklist Better than ACTeRS: The Swanson, Nolan, and Pelham (SNAP) checklist from the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, revised 3rd edition (DSM-III-R) has been shown to have a sensitivity and specificity in excess of 94% to distinguish hyperactive, inattentive, and impulsive children with ADHD from those without ADHD. This was based on criteria in the DSM-III-R. The DSM-IV SNAP checklist (available at www.adhd.net/snap-iv-form.pdf; scoring at www.adhd.net/snap-iv-instructions.pdf), based on the newer diagnostic criteria, has not been adequately evaluated. The ADHD Rating Scale-IV (in DuPaul et al, ADHD Rating Scale IV-Checklists, Norms, and Clinical Interpretations, available from Guilford Press) and the ADD-H Comprehensive Teacher/Parent Rating Scale (ACTeRS; available from MetriTech, Inc at www.metritech.com) are useful for their brevity, but they do not perform as well in differentiating children with ADHD from those without ADHD. Does a short symptom checklist accurately diagnose ADHD? Zolotor A, Mayer J, Hill J. University of North Carolina. J Fam Pract. 2004 May;53(5):412-6 Adult ADHD Rating Scales Oversensitive: Adult
ADHD is estimated between 0.3% and 5% of the population, a huge range.
Researchers examined the diagnostic and screening utility of three ADHD scales
(Adult Rating Scale [ARS], Attention-Deficit Scales for Adults [ADSA], and
Symptom Inventory for ADHD) in 82 adults presenting for ADHD evaluation. All
three instruments were sensitive to the presence of symptoms in adults with ADHD
(supposedly correctly identifying 78% to 92% of patients with ADHD), but a high proportion
of individuals with non-ADHD diagnoses screened positive (incorrectly
identifying between 36% and 67% of non-ADHD patients). Screening and diagnostic
utility of self-report attention deficit hyperactivity disorder scales in
adults. McCann BS, Roy-Byrne P. Compr Psychiatry. 2004
May-Jun;45(3):175-83. Ed: In fact, ADHD is not an illness. It is a
bunch of subjective symptoms artificially grouped together. There are
numerous medical illnesses of the brain which can have the symptoms of ADHD
along with other symptoms. These include a variety of genetic disorders,
head trauma victims, sleep apnea victims, infants born to nicotine and other
drug abusing mothers, children with high lead levels, etc. Each of these
is a different disease. ADHD is not a disease. If you gave
stimulants to normal students, they would report better ability to focus.
They would sit more quietly. Many would say that the stimulants helped
them. In fact, stimulants are vastly overrated. It reminds me
sometimes of the 1960's "OK everybody. Let's everybody get stoned"
mentality. There is no long-term research using double-blind studies
showing improvement on academic or work performance. While I will agree
that it is likely that some, carefully selected children may need stimulants for
behavior control, let's not fool ourselves. Both stimulants and other
psychiatric medications are being vastly over-utilized. |